How do you know you’re free?

By Don Cunningham/Tribune correspondent
Monday, Jun 30, 2008 - 11:10:41 am CDT

Mass naturalization of people will occur Friday. Twenty or thirty rows of them. In some community hall. With a flag overhead. Red, white and blue lapel pins for souvenirs.

Young and old will raise one hand while their voices - some stammering, others smooth - issue a modern and very personal declaration of independence.

Joining up. After getting accustomed to, they are now becoming part of, America.

The networks will run a sound bite at six.

Sea to shining sea is a nice little catch phrase. If you like east-west relations.

But it doesn’t capture America.

No sense trying to create a north-south jingle either. Hawaii and Alaska would object.

This problem began with a mapmaker who, in a fit of misguided enthusiasm, wrote "America" upon the scrawled manuscripts of explorers, who basically traveled rivers, forayed into adjoining lands, cleared some trees and built a few houses.

We concluded America was a place. Our house. Ours.

History should forgive this oversight. We were part of the expanding European empires at first. British. French. Spanish.

They missed the point.

American was always an idea.

In fairness to our ancestors, it was all about primitive annexation then. Land grabbing, to be accurate.

Of course, all Europeans were illegal immigrants. Advanced weaponry and aggressive conflicts with the native populations produced catastrophic results to Indian cultures in both hemispheres.

Enslavement. Confinement. Treaties were used for toilet paper in frontier outhouses.

Headlines today suggest that some people aren’t playing by the rules of immigration.

Not sure we ever have.

The Cunningham family didn’t, I can confess to that. So no stones being tossed from this corner.

Great-grandpa Matthew stowed away on a ship. Didn’t find him until it was too far for him to swim back. Which, if he represented the combined aquatic skills of his progeny, was about 25 feet. He was an Irish cop. I believe that placed him at odds with the majority of my clan who typically inhabited the other side of the bars.

Rest assured, more kin would certainly have accompanied blessed Matthew, but those locks were hard to pick.

Now don’t be too hard on ol’ Matt. Everyone wanted to come to America. He was one of thousands.

Too many to count or control or feed or welcome.

Didn’t matter. America, and its idealistic partner, freedom, were, and have always been, magnets.

No need to be tired or poor either.

The compass pointed to Ellis Island. Get in line. Serving freedom at the front.

So dear reader, in the days leading to this Fourth of July, answer this question: How do you know you are free?

(Like a good teacher, I will give you time to answer here.)

Your right to vote? To worship as you please? To live unrestrained? To travel unencumbered? To choose from a selection? Just how do you define freedom?

Hopefully, some news anchor will offer that question to our newest citizens Friday.

Our culture is constantly subject to revision, you know. Age after age. Generation upon generation.

America.

The idea of it.

Don Cunningham of Fremont is a regular contributor to the Tribune’s Opinion page.

Leave a Comment

All posts are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Email Address Required
   
Bobo
Jul 1, 2008 9:45 PM
Hey, Don:
Normally I find you columns uninspiring. Not this time. Props to you and the Trib for actually publishing something that none of the "deport all the illegals" crowd would ever admit: That our ancestors, of which the masses are so proud, were nothing but a bunch of illegal "invaders" themselves. There is no other way to spin it.
Ironically, if the current wave of immigrants were from a communist country, they'd be embraced as heroes instead of criminals.
The other irony is that the same hard-core "deport 'em all" crowd is their own worst enemy. By holding to that stance, immigration reform will never happen. The reality is that massive deportation will never, ever happen. There's too much money and too many votes at stake.
In their hearts the "deporters" know you're right. That's why after 2 days not a one of them have bothered to scratch out a response. Normally, they'd be all over you. Maybe they didn't understand the simple irony of your column.
How is freedom defined? Good question. Apparently, as you've pointed out, it means invading a land that does not belong to you and then subjugating its inhabitants to a demeaning and humiliating existence. Militarily and/or economically. Then repeat. Over and over. Then it means shooting off some blackcats and bottle rockets in "remembrance" of these great feats of which most haven't a clue.
What a country.
William Wallace
Jul 2, 2008 7:17 AM
A conversation pertaining to "fredom" has very little to do with immigration on this or any July 4th.

Are we "free" because we are told we are free from the moment of our birth? If we work harder to pay the banker, taxes, state required insurance, health insurance; are we not slaves of those whom we owe? All we have done is change our view point of who is the master.

If your grass is over 13" you are free to get a court date. If you are pulled over for speeding, you don't hear the words "can i see your papers"; but people live in fear of driving without their license on their person, is that free? You can't even pick up a prescription without giving your adress or showing identification, is that freedom?



We are a nation of sheep, the media, the politicians, they shape our opinions, and allow us to carry out their wishes; often to our own detriment.

The big question is why are we suddenly concerned about illegal immegration, it was mentioned briefly in the 80's. Why now,,,,now the media has taken up the drum beat,,,why?
Tex
Jul 2, 2008 9:44 AM
I totally agree with this column and both postings. We are a country of immigrants EXCEPT for those that are Native American. Maybe THEY should have had us all deported---history tells us they should have, the way we ended up treating them. I hate it when people act so superior to todays immigrants, lets not forget where we all came from, some legal, some not. Far as I know my ancestors were legal but they all came here for a better life just like todays legal and illegal immigrants. Lets not be so harsh on them.
Brian
Jul 2, 2008 6:12 PM
I think this is a good colum in general.
While I do not condone in anyway the brutality to Native Americans by the early white settlers, the "native" Americans were not native. Thier genetic ancestors came over from Siberia & mongolia via an Alaskan landbridge that no longer exists. Theese people eventually settled Southward and ended up being the Aztec & Inca empires of their day. If one goes back far enough. In truth NO race is actually native to the US.
No one is against LEGAL immigration. Its the ILLEGAL immigrants that has been swarming over the borders the past several years. There has always been people sneaking accross the borders, but its been "epidemic" proportions in the past 10-15 years is what has people upset. My family ancestors immigrated here LEGALLY through Ellis Island in the mid to late 1800s. We did it with the propper papers & checks of the day. Plus they learned English when ordered to during the World War I years. They assimilated with the rest of society of the time.
Have a good day all.
Former Fremonter
Jul 2, 2008 9:49 PM
To Bobo:

Our ancestors...didnt SNEAK in..bring drugs...cheat our Govt...destroy suburban developments...invoke terrorisitic activities...I cant believe that you could support Illegals and give them a free pass regardless of nationality....I used to believe in the system.....our future..our leaders....but the world is a different place now...its not neighbor helping neighbor ......the USA isnt the promised land anymore.....I love this country and our Brave Soldiers that defend our ability to sit here and Blog in peace...but i really think its time to look inward and develope our own shortcomings....help our pverty stricken...our Hurricane victims....our flood victims....we are so ready to hand out a blank check to the world to help them out and we leave OUR OWN countrymen behind....you take a long think on that one......Isolationism isnt a dirty word...its practical reasoning given the Worlds stance on our democratic ways and the way we try to spread it......you say theres too much money involved in our illegals involvement in the election....can you put a price on OUR OWN people in need...what if it was you floating away in Iowa...or You sitting in Louisisana waiting for the WAYYYY overdue FEMA involvement......I mean come on we have enough troubles to deal with If your Not a legal citizen your an Illegal citizedn and you deserved to be shoved out the door
Bobo
Jul 3, 2008 12:55 PM
To FF:
I find your post quite amusing. You say:

"the USA isnt the promised land anymore"
"I used to believe in the system"
"we have enough troubles to deal with"
"i really think its time to look inward and develope our own shortcomings"

Then you say:
"our democratic ways and the way we try to spread it"

Then you're confused when no other sovereign nation wants our "way" imposed on them?
america will be
Jul 5, 2008 7:49 PM
I like that there is still work to do. To steal from Churchill, we are the least perfect country, except for all the others. We all live in a boundless Monticello: Jefferson's own home was always being revised. We live in a country constantly under construction, and that's a good thing.
Bobo
Jul 5, 2008 10:11 PM
To awb:
Until our "house" is finished, we have no business imposing it on others who may be constructing their own.
Tex
Jul 6, 2008 9:54 AM
We should not impose our government or ways on other countries anymore than we like other countries doing that. I understand sometimes things are incredibly dire like Hitler's Germany but in general, we do not have the right to impose our ways on other countries.
america will be
Jul 6, 2008 9:06 PM
Bobo: yes, you get it.
Candy
Jul 7, 2008 9:30 AM
William Wallace...Thank you !!
My exact thoughts while reading this article.
Skittles
Jul 7, 2008 10:05 AM
Don is actually trying to cover a real topic instead of his usual mindless skittles and ice cream columns. Which I profess I hardly ever read and only read this one because it was in most commented area.
I think some of you are giving too much credit. I really don't think he had a hidden message here. He may have stumbled onto one unintentionally but I really think he just wanted to point out that his ancestors couldn't swim and liked to drink.
Now quick Don, I hear there will be a water baloon fight hosted by parks and rec this week.
Story Photo
Print This Story Email This Story

Blogs

Calendar of Events

Photos